![]()
|
Book ReviewsBoyle, Alan, and Michael Anderson (eds). Human Rights Approaches to
Environmental Protection. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996. Pp 313. The condition of the environment is inextricably linked to our social
and economic well-being. As the title suggests, this book addresses the extent
to which human rights should be mobilized, interpreted and reinvented - not
only procedurally but also substantively - to achieve environmental ends. This book, a collection of 14 essays, begins with a comprehensive
overview and a chapter on the conceptual problems that arise when approaching
environmental issues through a human rights framework. It then considers the
desirability of reconceiving international law in human rights terms, in
particular as an anthropocentric right, and assesses the current legal status
of environmental rights in human rights treaties and in the European Union. The
accountability of international institutions is the next focus, with a
discussion on non-governmental organizations' use of participation rights to
pursue environmental protection goals. The second part begins with a useful jurisprudential perspective on
judicial enforcement of constitutionally recognized environmental rights,
comparing the United States approach with that of India. Utilizing case
studies, the second part focuses on the application of environmental rights in
domestic law and the extent to which constitutionally supported rights have
been translated into everyday environmental management. Illustrative examples
from South Africa, India, Malaysia, Ecuador, Brazil and Pakistan reveal that
political and economic factors frequently obstruct the potential for
enforcement of environmental rights. The book provides the reader with a
thorough appreciation of the issues and challenges facing a human rights
approach to an environmental question. Charmian Barton Harvard Law School
|
|
|
© 1990-2004 European Journal of International Law | ||